Skip to main content
Digestate

Is Digestate Better Than Slurry?

It's a natural comparison to make, but 'better' depends on what you're measuring. Here's what digestion actually changes, and what it doesn't.

7 min read · Reviewed September 2026

Tensioning the digester cover during tank construction

Quick Answer

Digestate is not simply universally better than slurry. Anaerobic digestion changes the material and can make a greater proportion of nitrogen readily available to crops, while retaining many nutrients. Its value depends on composition, storage, application timing, soil and crop requirements — not a fixed comparison that holds for every farm.

Key Points

  • Digestion changes slurry's nitrogen availability, not simply its overall nutrient content
  • Digestate generally retains most of the nutrients present in the original feedstock
  • Odour can be reduced, but shouldn't be assumed eliminated
  • The genuine value of either material depends on farm-specific testing and application

What changes during anaerobic digestion?

During digestion, microorganisms break down part of the biodegradable organic material in slurry, producing biogas. That biological process also changes the chemical form some of the remaining nutrients are in — most notably nitrogen, a portion of which converts into ammonium nitrogen, a form more readily available to growing crops than the organic nitrogen present in untreated slurry.

What remains — organic matter and other nutrients

Digestion doesn't remove most of what slurry contains. Digestate generally retains much of the phosphorus, potassium and organic matter present in the original feedstock, alongside the nitrogen — it's a transformation, not a reduction to a lesser material.

Nitrogen availability — the main practical difference

The shift toward more readily available nitrogen is the most agronomically significant difference between digestate and untreated slurry. It can make digestate a more responsive fertiliser in the right conditions, but it also means the nitrogen is more prone to loss if applications are poorly timed or the material isn't incorporated promptly — good news and a management requirement at the same time.

Odour

Digestion can reduce some of the odour associated with untreated slurry, but digestate isn't odourless, and how much odour reduction a particular farm actually experiences depends on the whole system, not the digester alone — covered in more detail in our guide on anaerobic digestion and slurry smell.

Storage, land application and nutrient testing

Digestate still needs proper storage, and still needs applying in line with normal agricultural rules for timing and location — digestion doesn't remove any of that responsibility. Because composition varies with feedstock and process, testing the actual material is a far better basis for fertiliser planning than assuming a fixed nutrient value, whether for slurry or digestate.

Where slurry and digestate genuinely differ in practice

In practice, the difference that matters most to a farm is usually nitrogen timing and availability, not a wholesale change in what the material can do. Situations where this matters most include crops with a defined nitrogen demand window, where digestate's more available nitrogen can be a genuine advantage if applied correctly — and a genuine risk of loss if it isn't.

Why farm-specific analysis matters more than a general comparison

Because composition, storage conditions and application method all affect the outcome, a general 'digestate versus slurry' comparison can only go so far. The more useful question for a specific farm is what its actual digestate analysis shows, and how that fits its own nutrient management plan — covered further in our guide on digestate's fertiliser value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources

PLANNING AN AD INSTALLATION?

Need help with the practical side of an AD project?

Charlie Bell Building supports farm-scale anaerobic digestion installations from site preparation and groundworks through to equipment installation and commissioning support.